I’m photographer Jay P. Morgan from The Slanted Lens. In this video and article, I’ll share with you an actual photoshoot fraud case and what to look for so that you don’t get taken by a fraudulent scam like it.
A “Florida man” almost defrauded us over at The Slanted Lens — they even sent us a check. I got an email early in November saying, “Hey, we want you to do a fashion shoot for Esquire magazine.” I’m thinking, “Esquire magazine?” Julene said, “Esquire magazine? You’re not a fashion shooter.” That hurt a little bit, but I’m a fashion shooter — fringe fashion. You know, I’ve shot people with clothes on before. Actually, that’s all I’ve ever shot, people with clothes on.
I’m thinking, “What’s a fashion shoot?” And the money was standard (okay, not great). But I started exchanging emails with this individual. Let me set out exactly how they set this fraud up and exactly what they did. Let’s take a look at it.
It’s amazing how elaborate this was. I got a complete breakdown on the shoot. There was to be one outfit per model, five images of the models together, outfits and wardrobe will be supplied by us. They sent a complete breakdown of the kind of images that they wanted. The photographer’s compensation was $4,000. The talent fees were $4,000.
And then it goes on and on and on. And they sent a contract as well — one that just talks about reshoots and loss of damages. I mean, it’s a pretty typical contract. Someone’s pulled this somewhere from the Internet.
The contract goes through the compensation saying how much you’ll make and you have to pay the talent. It’s all in the contract that you pay the modeling agency the $4,000, and then it has a place to sign on the bottom to send it back into them. I was dumb enough to sign it and send it back. I’m trying to get this stuff done and it out of here. And I picked a date for the shoot, I signed it and sent it back.
Everything seemed legit until I said, “We just need to have a call, I need to get on a call with you.” And then he said, “Well, you should talk to so and so. The check has arrived. Now you have the check.” I replied, “I don’t have a check.” He replied, “You do have a check.” I said, “Well, I don’t have a check.” I never gave him an address or anything.
And they shipped me a check. And the check is just bizarre. It’s a check for $6,000. But then the person started emailing, so now I kind of knew what was going on and I’m pushing them.
So what am I supposed to do now? He goes, “You need to send $4,000 to the modeling agency.” Well, I don’t know who the modeling agency is. They need to send me an invoice. And so the modeling agency sends me an invoice.
I said, “Where do I send the money?” It just kept getting more and more. I mean, it kept going on. They tried really hard to get me to send a check to the modeling agency, the $4,000. The agency was not in Los Angeles. And it was not an agency that I had heard of before.
Agencies That Don’t Exist
So there was a red flag. I know the agencies that are in LA. It’s not hard too hard to verify them and to call them up and to see who’s there and look cup on the website and see who the agents are.
It also happened over a holiday, which is a prime time because you’re in the midst of taking time off.
And it’s hard to get ahold of people a lot of times so you start to justify why this person isn’t responding or why it’s getting hard to be able to put this together. Just know if it’s over a holiday weekend, if it’s needing to happen fast (like “we need to have the shot by next Tuesday”), that kind of pressure coupled with the fact that I can’t get an art director on the phone just means it’s fraud.
Offers Outside Your Area of Expertise
First off, if it’s not your style of work, then it’s probably a fraud. If they send an email saying we really want you to do this high-end fashion shoot and it’s not the kind of work you do, it’s probably fraud. But they may be smart enough to send it to someone who does do fashion. And you really want a job and now you kind of start to fall for it a little bit.
Refusing to Communicate by Phone
Another red flag is they won’t get on a call. You know, almost every creative process I’ve ever been in, you get on the call with the art director, you talk about the project, you get a really good idea of exactly what they want.
How do you want the product shots? Products with and without the model? How do you want them delivered? Make them get on a call, if they won’t get on a call with you, then it’s not working. So just know if they won’t get on the call, then it’s probably fraud. But at the end of the video stick around, I’m going to talk about a scenario where they do get you on a call.
Even though the art director was an art director who worked at Esquire and they had set up an Instagram for this art director that worked at Esquire. All the communication for the art director was a Gmail address. My daughter works as an art director freelance a lot of times and even if she freelances for a company for any length of time for like six or eight weeks, they’ll give her an email at that company. So she can communicate as a member of that company. You don’t use your Gmail, your personal email.
Asking for Sensitive Information
Another red flag is when they want your bank account information. They either want that so they can get access to your account, or they want you to give a verification that you’ve deposited the check.
And that gives them this window where they know that they can get you to send money to somebody else because you think you have the money. And the check hasn’t bounced yet. They went so far as to send me a check from a homeowner’s association in Florida. When people start pushing for bank account information, pretty much a red flag, absolutely.
I have heard of scenarios where they do get you on a call. They have a conversation with you where they talk about the project. It’s all working. The way you can get around this is you just have to do some research. If the person gives you a number, get out of their loop. They want to keep you in a loop, a closed loop with their email and their phone number. They want you to be all in that loop.
If you step out of their loop, you look up the person’s name at whatever agency. Say they’re at Esquire, you find the person’s name at Esquire, and you find their contact information at Esquire. And then you try to call them, you’ve now stepped out of their loop. And you’re going to come in a backdoor to see if they’re real. And if you can’t find the art directors name at Esquire, and you can’t find contact information for that art director at Esquire, then you’re probably getting defrauded, even if they’re getting you on the phone.
I’ve heard of elaborate situations where they get you on the phone, they get you out on the project and you start spending for everything. And then pretty soon you’re giving money to all their friends and you get defrauded like that. So make sure you get outside of the loop and figure out if it’s real. It’s really important to do.
So there you have it. Florida man almost defrauds us over at The Slanted Lens. So if you have any of these situations that have ever happened to you, leave them in the comments below. I’d love to see anything or hear about anything that’s ever happened to you. Share with our community because it really helps everyone to know what’s going on out there and how they can protect themselves.
About the author: Jay P. Morgan is a commercial photographer with over two decades of experience in the industry. He teaches photography through his company, The Slanted Lens, which runs a popular YouTube channel. This review was also published here.